Skip to main content

The Difference Between Constructive Criticism & Criticism in Modeling

It goes without saying that modeling is a harsh business. Models are in a profession where being judged and evaluated is just another day at the office.

Those who've been in the industry for a long time certainly have the thick skin needed to get through but it's only natural that newbies may have a tougher time getting used to such an uncommon learning curve.

I think what is important for newer models starting out to keep in mind is to put everything in perspective. As I've mentioned in previous blog posts, any feedback--positive or negative--isn't a direct reflection of who the model is as a person. It's just business.

Piggybacking off that concept, it is vital for new female and male models alike to understand the difference between criticism and constructive criticism.

CRITICISM: Pointing out certain faults, flaws, mistakes or shortcomings in a disapproving manner.

Example: "Your runway walk is sloppy and your posture is terrible."

CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM: Pointing out certain faults, flaws, mistakes or shortcomings but in a more positive manner by providing well-reasoned opinions and feedback to back up those criticisms.

Example: "Your runway walk could use more work. Definitely practice more to get familiar with the way your body moves and focus on better posture. Walk with your chest out and shoulders back, not hunched over."

Clearly what all models want to receive is constructive criticism. It's not a matter of trying to sugarcoat feedback but what I appreciate about the use of constructive criticism is the fact that it serves as a teaching moment.

By providing the "why" behind the feedback, this ultimately serves models much better compared to simply telling them what's wrong or what they did wrong and offering nothing else.

Unfortunately, not everyone in the modeling industry (from clients and photographers to modeling agencies) will use constructive criticism so be prepared for that. There are those in the industry who feel that if you want to make it in modeling, you just have to "deal with it" and learn how to take negative feedback.

However, there are many others who don't look at things in that manner and who do recognize the importance of how useful constructive criticism is.

Where this type of criticism comes into play a lot is when working with photographers. Doing photoshoots is the primary way models gain hands-on experience when it comes to posing, camera presence, facial expressions, etc. The more shoots you do, the more you can gain that valuable constructive criticism from photographers who can offer their insight as to what could be improved (if anything) and tips for performing at your best.

Meeting with modeling agencies during open calls or in a formal sit-down interview is another situation where the opportunity for constructive criticism could come up--namely when it comes to asking aspiring fashion models to do a runway walk. While doing this kind of walk in front of agency staff can be nerve wracking, it is very important to absorb the feedback you're given afterwards.

If they point out certain things you did wrong or say that you need to work on something, don't take that to mean it's totally negative criticism. Agencies tend to get right to the point, which could at first be seen as regular criticism but in most cases, they will offer advice or tips for how to correct the issues they've pointed out. This is where the "constructive" part comes in.

Of course there will be times when you'll just run into straight up criticism. It is difficult to handle at first and could throw you off your game but instead of reacting or getting defensive, take a moment to think about what's been said and simply ask what you can do to improve. People who don't understand the difference between criticism and constructive criticism usually never even think to provide a reason as to why they said what they did or have the common sense to make suggestions so by politely and professionally requesting feedback or instruction, it could turn a potentially negative situation into a better one.

Will there be people in the industry who could care less about offering constructive criticism and will just say what they want to say to a model and put him/her down? Yes, but thankfully, those types of folks aren't abundant in modeling. There are many more who do practice constructive criticism and use it to make the industry a much more properly functioning business.

The bottom line: don't be too sensitive when it comes to getting feedback about your modeling skills. Take it in stride, absorb, reflect, ask questions and apply what you've been told. With constructive criticism, this is much easier to do but even with negative criticism, do what you can to turn it into a learning lesson that you will ultimately benefit from rather than allowing harsh words to set you back.

Remember, the keyword in constructive criticism is the word "constructive." This of this word and its purpose like the word "construction": it's about building you up, not knocking you down.

Comments

Lisa said…
Example: "Your runway walk is sloppy and your posture is terrible."

Whoever says that is a jerk.

Example: "Your runway walk could use more work. Definitely practice more to get familiar with the way your body moves and focus on better posture. Walk with your chest out and shoulders back, not hunched over."

This is even better because then the model will improve more and succeed.
Anonymous said…
Hi Dania!
This is a really random question but yeah ahahahaha. How come female models' don't wear bras when they are doing a fashion show??

Thank you!
Dania Denise said…
Hi, Anonymous! You'll find the answer to your questions in its own post, titled "Answering a Reader Question #697," which can be found on my other blog: "Modeling 101 - Answering Readers Questions."

Please visit this link: http://amodelsdiary-readerquestions.blogspot.com/ and you can view your post there. Thanks for reading!
Anonymous said…
Hello Dania!
A really quick questions! Is there any fees that I'm expected to pay for fit modelling? Like does fit modelling have comp cards or something?

Also, what have you been up to these days? :D

Thanks a lot!
Dania Denise said…
Hi, Anonymous! You'll find the answer to your questions in its own post, titled "Answering a Reader Question #699," which can be found on my other blog: "Modeling 101 - Answering Readers Questions."

Please visit this link: http://amodelsdiary-readerquestions.blogspot.com/ and you can view your post there. Thanks for reading!
Dania Denise said…
ATTN ANONYMOUS WHO WROTE:

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "The Difference Between Constructive Criticism & Cr...":

Hi Dania!
I read a bunch of your reader questions so now I have one of my own:

I was wondering how much models get paid. Like, is it enough to make a living off of? Also I'm in 8th grade and I'm not sure if I should consider modeling in the future. I would love to model, but I'm scared the pay won't be enough.

Thanks! <3
________________________

I'm SO sorry, I accidentally deleted your comment and the site won't let me undo the action so I really hope you see this comment!

You'll find the answer to your questions in its own post, titled "Answering a Reader Question #705," which can be found on my other blog: "Modeling 101 - Answering Readers Questions."

Please visit this link: http://amodelsdiary-readerquestions.blogspot.com/ and you can view your post there. Thanks for reading!

Popular posts from this blog

Modeling & Pay Rates: How Much Should You Charge?

(This post is more targeted towards freelance models and not those with agency representation, although it may apply to those that have an agent but continue to find their own work.) A part of being a successful model is making money from the jobs that you book. However, being a freelance model comes with many challenges--figuring out what you should charge is one of them. I will say upfront that there are no established black and white rules when it comes to pay rates. Each modeling job is different, each client is different and budgets vary. Ultimately the factors that should influence what you charge should be the amount of experience you have, the strength of the images in your portfolio and the client's budget/needs. Not every client is going to pay what you want to charge. There may be times when you will be skipped over for charging too much or taken advantage of for charging too little. It's going to happen so be prepared for it and do not take it personally. It

What Are Male Models Supposed to Look Like?

The modeling world is filled with women. That's never been a secret and sadly, that often means male models fall by the wayside. There are successful male models in all categories across the industry but the fact that the modeling business revolves around women can make it challenging for newbies to figure out how to pursue their goals of male modeling. It is important to know that because there are different types of modeling categories out there, that means there are also different types of male models. They aren't all supposed to look alike and what ends up being in demand does change every year. Let's break down the common attributes that come with male modeling in various popular categories, shall we? THE MALE FASHION/RUNWAY/EDITORIAL MODEL These are the typical types of models most of us tend to think of when it comes to men in modeling. What is important to know and understand if you're an aspiring male model is that agencies have all different looks

Modeling and Weight

One of the first things I hear potential models ask is what the weight requirement for modeling is. Sometimes that is the main issue they worry about when it comes to pursuing modeling. Let me tell you right now that weight should NOT be one of those concerns. Obviously, the height requirement reigns supreme when measuring up to the modeling standards sought out by agencies. If you meet the height requirements--whether it's for fashion and runway or commercial/print--that is the first step towards starting on the path to modeling. How much you weigh shouldn't be your biggest fear. It is rare that anyone can look at someone and say, "Oh, my gosh, he/she looks like they are 5 pounds over our weight requirement!" It just isn't realistic. If you look at many modeling agency websites, they clearly list the age and height requirements--rarely, if at all do they list any weight restrictions. The general rule of thumb when it comes to weight is that for models who